Primary Blog/The Supreme Court Ruling Every Small Carrier Should Understand

The Supreme Court Ruling Every Small Carrier Should Understand

If freight access is tightening or insurance rates are jumping, a recent Supreme Court decision is a major reason why.

What the Court ruled

On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II that freight brokers can be sued for negligently selecting unsafe carriers. This removed the federal statutory shield brokers previously used to dismiss injury lawsuits early.

The ruling did not set safety score cutoffs or mandate specific carrier criteria. It simply exposed brokers to jury trials if they hire carriers they should have known were unsafe.

The broker reaction impacting your fleet

Brokers responded immediately to protect themselves. C.H. Robinson, for example, now demands a minimum of $1 million in auto liability coverage and refuses to certify carriers with Conditional or Unsatisfactory ratings. Other brokers are following suit.

And recent multi-million dollar verdicts show even Satisfactory-rated carriers can be pulled into these cases, so brokers are vetting safety data aggressively across the board.

What you need to do

Your safety record is no longer just a regulatory metric. It is your key to securing freight.

  • If you carry a Conditional rating, petition FMCSA for an upgrade immediately.
  • Monitor your safety file regularly to correct issues before brokers flag your DOT number.
  • Maintain at least $1 million in liability coverage.

Download our free guide on the
compliance leaks that drain small carriers
and trigger broker red flags.

Download our free guide on the compliance leaks that drain small carriers and trigger broker red flags.

Helping Trucking Companies turn compliance into profits

W175N11163 Stonewood Drive, Ste 108, Germantown, WI 53022

hello@truckingwins.com

↑